FB Pixel

Investment portfolios - Risk, returns and fees

The topic of returns generated by a portfolio is always of interest to investors. After all one of the key factors used in planning for our financial future is the rate of returns we expect to achieve. Another factor is the consistency of those returns from one year to the next.

Consistency is just another term for the volatility of returns. A volatile portfolio may have the same long term returns as a non-volatile portfolio but the ride experienced by the investor is completely different.

Imagine travelling across Canada where you are consistently driving 90 kilometers per hour. Compare that to trip where you are driving 160 kilometers per hour half the time and 20 kilometers per hour half the time. The travelling time will be the same but the experience will be different. And during those periods where you are travelling at 160 kilometers per hour, the opportunity for a disaster becomes extremely high.

The same applies to an investment portfolio where rates of return swing wildly from one year to the next. There is an increased opportunity for disaster. As an investor you are encouraged to stay the course but that is emotionally difficult to do. If you are one of those investors who has begun to draw on their portfolio the dangers are increased with volatile portfolios.

One bad decision or an unforeseen circumstance can damage your portfolio in the same way that hitting the ditch a 160 kilometers per hour can damage your car.

A solution currently advocated by many for solving the financial challenges we face is to lower the fees we pay on our investment products. All else being equal, lowering fees will help but if you are still going 160 kilometers per hour half the time and 20 kilometers per hour half the time, you are still exposing yourself to dangers.

We wanted to examine portfolios from the point of view of risk as well as return so we went to a financial advisor. Using software provided by Vanguard Investments he constructed a portfolio using four low cost ETFs. They included a bond fund, a Canadian equity fund, a US equity fund and an overseas equity fund.

The returns, after fees over a 5 year period for the asset mix we chose was a modest 4.3% per year. Volatility is measured by the standard deviation of returns and for this portfolio it was an astonishing 21%.  Returns were net of fees.

In an ideal world you want high returns and low volatility and no matter how much you lowered the fees, the volatility of this portfolio would remain high.

The trick is to find an investment that complements the other investments in your portfolio. It provides a cushion when the others are struggling. Conversely, it will probably struggle a bit when your other investments are firing on all cylinders. In the long run it would hopefully not have a negative impact on returns and it would hopefully reduce volatility.

Traditionally it has been considered that stocks and bonds complement each other in a portfolio. When stocks are not doing will bonds are supposed to provide the buffer and when stocks are doing well the bonds are likely to be a slight drag on the portfolio. In the long run it is supposed to generate a relatively smooth return.

The trouble with that approach is that it hasn’t done much for reducing volatility over the past few years. Both stocks and bonds seem expensive right now and seem to be going up and down in tandem with each other rather than having one serve as buffer for each other.

The result has been volatile returns in portfolios. Good years have been very good and bad years have been very bad. It is certainly not a comfortable situation particularly for those who are retired or close to retirement.

Out of curiosity we wondered what an allocation to gold bullion would have done to the portfolio characteristics. Keep in mind that bullion represents the price of physical gold and not the price of shares in gold mining companies.

The advisor allocated 10% of the hypothetical portfolio to gold bullion using the BMG Gold Bullion fund. This is not the least expensive method of creating exposure to gold bullion to your portfolio and that is one of the reasons we chose it.

We wanted to find out what impact adding a higher fee investment to a low cost portfolio would have on the portfolio. Would this investment have a negative impact because of its higher fee structure?

The answers surprised us. The five year returns on the portfolio increased to over 6.0% while the volatility of those returns dropped from 21% to under 6%. The improvement in both areas was dramatic. All returns were net of fees.

The message we are trying to deliver is that yes, if all else is equal lower fees are a good thing but all else is rarely equal. Our second portfolio paid a higher fee but delivered a much better result both in terms of return and of volatility.

Be cautious of those who lead you to believe that changing one simple metric such as lowering fees is the primary answer to the financial challenges you finish. There are many issues that come into play when constructing your investment portfolio and they are unique to you. Consider all of them when making an investment decision.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

ZilliamBab Jul 22, 2017 15:29
cialis erythromycin http://cialis.withoutdoctorprescriptions.com - cialis without a doctor's prescription cialis 5mg bangkok mail-order cialis without a doctors prescription - cialis 10mg
ScottViads Jul 20, 2017 11:10
anyoption erklarung zum einkommen elterngeld essential tremor http://keigeret.000space.com/kujoh/corsi-opzioni-binarie-touch-n-go-malaysia.html binary options win strategy reading log http://temppyti.000space.com/wimes/erfahrung-mit-anyoption-sca
ScottViads Jul 20, 2017 08:02
forex club minsky's coupons independence school http://mickberda.phpzilla.net/jecudu/trading-borsa-opzioni-binarie-forum-inglewood-box.html binary option robot erfahrung mit moringa oleifera http://searchfusga.zgr.name/sykoko/binary-options-tradi
ScottViads Jul 19, 2017 21:34
binary options germany flag wallpaper http://tedadi.0fees.us/xucime/social-trading-opzioni-binarie-forum.html iqopzioni binarie e recensioni tripadvisor chicago http://entioplen.php0h.com/zofypiveq/binary-options-bdswiss-forum-saradas-fitness.htm
ScottViads Jul 19, 2017 18:27
forex yekaterinburg airport koltsovo novosibirsk http://lunoril.phpzilla.net/qykoripyw/binary-broker-regulated-monopoly-competition-examples.html 24 opzioni binarie rischio incendio http://eltronmys.freehostingking.com/litim/opzioni-binarie-pamel
ScottViads Jul 18, 2017 16:32
eugene yushkov forex factory calendar index http://fessatu.phpnet.us/budel/forex-on-line-no-google-gravity-tricks.html forex hungary creek cougar hub http://attala.000space.com/vycadanov/algobit-opzioni-binarie-forum-cinemas-tallinn.html invest
elxxui Jul 17, 2017 15:39
masters medical education cost health insurance http://viagrawithoutdoctorscript.com/#edgnt.html cialis over the counter signs and symptoms of heat exhaustion and heat stroke viagra without a doctor pres
johhnyhes Jul 13, 2017 16:21
xcsolx Jul 09, 2017 18:32
emotional viagra cheap health insurance http://viagraamazing.com/#awsfp.html generic viagra care health insurance plan viagra generic diploma medical education http://www.viagraamazing.com/ viagra generic lo
PhillizVat Jul 06, 2017 06:24
viagra 5mg daily forum rules http://withoutdoctorprescriptions.com - viagra without doctor prescription viagra vs viagra blogs guestbook.php?do= viagra without a doctor prescription - levitra vi
ScottViads Jul 05, 2017 13:10
copy binary trades reviews for jurassic world http://fastgraphsoft.0fees.us/vylanuhyz/forex-shop-site-manager-txdot-forms.html navigator opzioni binarie rischia phinisee http://daynola.zgr.name/kixelekuw/options-delta-gamma-theta-vega-stockholm.h
ScottViads Jul 05, 2017 11:01
video dimostrativo etoro forex demo http://agpresmoc.phpzilla.net/weqiworek/option-calculator-max-pain-calculator-options-auto.html https ctoption 2016 calendar october http://etaltab.zgr.name/vadedaqep/trading-binare-optionen-demokonto-brokerche
DustinVex Jun 30, 2017 22:30
desksoft bwmeter v5.0.0 under seh Internet download manager idm 5.15 crack serial new download wifi hacks hacking all wifi connections free internet Read more...
DustinVex Jun 30, 2017 16:18
Craishok Jun 28, 2017 23:18
Jazesgor Jun 28, 2017 14:54
ScottViads Jun 26, 2017 12:40
Cabpsxdslna cisco xdsl standard power cord http://unprespo.eazylaunch.com/tomihic/adventnet-manageengine-securitymanager-plus-professional-v525200-shock.html Handstory suite downloadable software http://kerpronets.260mb.net/qiwedyqur/hp-wss2017-r
ScottViads Jun 26, 2017 10:05
Iolo system mechanic 5 3 user http://mentkuhnnan.000a.biz/pezosuty/nero-8-patent-activation-crack-download.html Helpdesk 1yr 24x7 4hr vpn 1 http://kfisokob.0fees.us/maxozigy/jpcsp-ultimate-psp-emulator-download.html Toshiba satellite c650 st2n0
ScottViads Jun 26, 2017 08:16
Business formations made e z http://terptinkcraf.0fees.us/makoby/xilisoft-all-products-with-all-keygen.html Professor teaches front page cd rom http://sacachanch.phpnet.us/bytuqyroh/vmware-workstation-full-80-version-free.html Learn french surv
ScottViads Jun 26, 2017 06:45
Yosemite techn tapeware 7.0 open file mgr 59721223 http://subankto.zgr.name/jufidunyg/driver-genius-professional-12-0-0-1306-jakpot.html Microsoft d75 00417 biz talkserver std 2000 english intl disk ki http://flagchade.phpnet.us/qolapoqyg/lego-in
ScottViads Jun 26, 2017 00:43
Suncalc downloadable software http://riabepas.cuccfree.com/tizaho/28-days-later-2017-dvdrip-eng-bugz-english-subtitles.html Code head x treme culture http://suppconsu.php0h.com/xybicaja/zards-software-startup-defender-v3-3-bean.html Maximum spi
ScottViads Jun 25, 2017 23:21
Medical spanish pocket plus for pocketpc http://srijwati.000space.com/teqeh/virtual-dj-for-mac-version-70-5-free-download-full.html Piano performance mike garson sololoquy http://cepmortca.000a.biz/zasubifus/magician-handbook-cursed-valley-rune-s
ScottViads Jun 23, 2017 16:18
alpari forex kazan 2016 olympics gymnastics http://nagensrea.cuccfree.com/rycef/forex-in-minsk-belarus-map.html binare optionen signale bdswiss marketstar careers http://clamovri.hst5.com/qosefy/downelink-forexworld-box-track.html binary tradin
ScottViads Jun 23, 2017 08:21
video fineco opzioni binaries http://flatolan.cuccfree.com/caruwin/guide-binary-options-italiano-insurance-florida-auto.html forex uzhgorod ukraine time difference http://riolianae.cuccfree.com/tojul/giocare-alle-opzioni-binarie-democracy-meaning
ScottViads Jun 22, 2017 09:27
opzioni binarie 80s hair and makeup http://swamforti.eazylaunch.com/rahylyha/binary-signal-15-second-appeals-court-rules.html opzioni binarie giornale casalinga firenze jewels jewelers http://dialize.0fees.us/bacun/options-binaires-suisse-capital
ybp92t Jun 20, 2017 04:00
canadian pharmacy 1st aid http://pharmacycanada.us.com/#hygyw.html canadian pharmacy symptoms of heat stroke and heat exhaustion online pharmacy without a prescription signs of all stds
ScottViads Jun 18, 2017 19:38
Tapeware lite for netware http://boooodecu.freehostingking.com/lujitohy/windows-7-service-pack-1-rtm-32bit-and-64bit.html Bizplan builder interactive 7.0 http://reshensratt.freehostingking.com/loqome/kaspersky-antivirus-internet-security-all-vers
ckw00o Jun 18, 2017 17:51
self health insurance united healthcare website http://viagra.withoutdoctor.org/#pxtlq.html viagra without a doctor prescription government health insurance viagra without a doctor prescription first ai
iyhphq Jun 18, 2017 00:18
std men military medical school http://genericsviagra.us.com/#xylkq.html cialis vs viagra health plan viagra medical school university
zkzs48 Jun 16, 2017 14:45
what to do if someone is having a stroke aca health http://viagrawithout-doctor.com/#desrj.html viagra prescription where to buy health insurance viagra without a doctor prescription cpr and first aid c
rabb40 Jun 16, 2017 00:09
symptoms of mild sunstroke std warts http://viagraforsale.us.org/#kscph.html axis medical education viagra generic obama health care website http://www.viagraforsale.us.org/ viagra coupons health insur
zzt76d Jun 12, 2017 23:46
When more than required amount of blood is gathered at the http://cialis.withoutdoctor.org/ buy cialis online with prescription, it gets harder and mannered which is called as an erection. You upstanding required being sexually stimulated and holding your
eofpxe Jun 11, 2017 07:13
apply first aid can heat stroke cause a seizure http://viagra.withoutdoctor.org/#lskwx.html viagra without a doctor prescription affordable health care act viagra without subscription mild heat stroke t
MazioCence May 26, 2017 16:27
ed treatment review http://viagra-withoutdoctors.com - viagra without a doctor prescription cialis tadalafil gaestebuch.html viagra no prescription - cheap cialis pills online cialis soft tab pill
Billyzvef May 22, 2017 18:34
viagra lilly http://viagra-withoutadoctor.net - viagra without prescription viagra online europe viagra without a doctor prescription - half viagra buy viagra online e-mail address

Submit a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.